A few weeks ago Orin and I were having a lazy weekend morning and headed over to a neighborhood bagel shop for breakfast. While we sat in the shop and enjoyed the toasted doughy treats, I got to thinking.... “How do you even make bagels? Is it difficult?” It’s not something you hear about many people doing in their own at home, so I assumed that it must be some lengthy, involved, complicated process that only really experienced bakers in professional shops would attempt. A few days later, my curiosity got the best of me and I started doing a little research. I found a few online articles with directions and recipes, all of which made the process seem relatively easy. And so, I took the next logical step and decided to give it a try for myself.
As I do before attempting almost anything new in the kitchen, I turned to The Joy of Cooking. I have found The Joy of Cooking to be a great resource for basic recipes and directions, although I rarely follow Irma’s instructions and ingredients to the T. I often use the recipes as a starting point only, adapting each recipe to my own preferences and needs. That being said, the bagel recipe found in the JOC turned out to need only a few minor adjustments.

Knowing very little about doughs or bread-making, I decided to try and follow Irma’s exact recipe for bagels. So, I blindly added each ingredient at the specified amounts and ended up with a very dense and dry ball of useless dough. I promptly tossed the pitiful lump and decided to give it another go. From then on, I used my own judgment when it came to the amount of flour that was needed. Thus I learned that one of the basics to dough making is adding flour gradually in small amounts and only until the desired texture is achieved.

By my third attempt, I finally figured out what that desired texture is and how to go about achieving it. With bagels, that desired texture is best described as smooth and elastic. The simplest way that I have come up with to determine when the dough is just right is to remember these three things: knead for at least 5 minutes and as much as 10 minutes, the dough should be uniform and easily shaped into one large ball, the dough should not stick to your hands.


Shaping the rings of dough was intimidating as first. I wanted my bagels to look nice as well as taste yummy. It took some practice, but I eventually developed a technique that works quite well. With the dough divided into equally-sized portions, I rolled them out into dough snakes of about 8-10 inches long.
*Orin and I tried two different sized bagels at this point. The JOC recipe calls for 8 bagels per batch, but we found that to result in some small bagels. So, we made batches of 6 and 4 bagels each. *

Then, I wrap the dough around the back of my hand and overlap the two ends of the snake in my palm.

Next, I roll that portion of the dough until a good seam has been formed. The key here is to make sure that the dough ends have “fused” together, otherwise they can split when the dough is boiled and baked.

Once the rings of dough have risen, it’s time to boil the bagels! This well-known step is what makes a bagel a bagel. This part of the process is just as simple as it sounds. I used a large slotted spatula to maneuver the dough rings in and out of the water.

I was surprised at how much the bagels puff up during their boiling bath. They got quite a bit larger and started to resemble a completed bagel. While the bagels were wet, I added toppings such as sesame seeds or dried onion flakes to some of the batches.

Due to the crazy nature of my unpredictable gas oven, I have had to pay special attention to the baking process. Some of the smaller bagels only required 8 minutes of baking on each side, while the larger bagels needed a full 10 or 11 minutes on each side.

The result? Lots of yummy, good looking breakfast treats that we can enjoy for up to a week. I still prefer mine rather simple, with cream cheese. However, we have experimented with fried egg bagel sandwiches, cheese, fruit, and marmalades. You may have also noticed that I experimented with some other bagel ingredients, adding blueberries to the dough and toppings before baking. All of the additions seemed to work out well and have only encouraged me to continue experimenting.

Try it for yourself! Happy kneading!
Preheat oven to 425⁰
Lightly oil a large baking sheet
Combine the following in a medium sized bowl and stir until well dissolved:
1 cup plus 2 Tablespoons warm water (105°-115°F)
1 package (2 ¼ teaspoons) active dry yeast
2 ½ teaspoons sugar
Stir in:
1 Tablespoon vegetable oil or melted butter
1 ½ teaspoons sugar
1 ¾ teaspoons salt
1 cup bread flour

Stir until well blended, then 50 strokes. Add any flavor ingredients at this point. (onion/garlic powder, raisins, cinnamon, blueberries, etc.)
Gradually begin adding between 2 and 3 cups of additional bread flour. The amount of flour will vary. Always add flour in small increments. Once you have the first additional cup of flour added, you should be able to transfer the dough onto a floured working surface. Continue adding flour gradually as you knead the dough. Kneading can be tricky. You want to try and stick to a few simple motions. Press the dough down with the heel of your hand, then fold the dough over from the top onto itself and press again, then repeat over and over. Knead for at least 5 minutes and as long as 10 minutes until the dough is smooth and elastic. Place in a bowl, cover, and let rise for 15 -20 minutes.
Once the dough has risen, knead out any air bubbles and cut into either 6 or 8 (depending on how big you want your bagels) equal sections of dough. Roll each section of dough out into 8-10 inch lengths. Overlap the ends of the dough and press together until well fused. Set the dough rings on a lightly floured surface, cover, and let rise for 15 -20 minutes. Fill a large pot with water and place on the stove to boil.
Once the dough rings have risen, you will place them in the water to boil (2 or 3 at a time, whatever will fit in the pot without overlapping). Boil for one minute on each side, remove from the water, then let dry.
Once the bagels are dry, place them on the oiled baking sheet. Bake for 10 minutes on each side at 425⁰. Remove from the oven and let cool completely.
Store in an airtight container to retain freshness up to 5-6 days!
Credit for all of the amazing photos goes to Orin Salah. Thanks for all of your help and support!